Is Your Garbage Disposal Leaking? When to Repair and When to Replace
Magnificent Plumbing Logo

Enquire Now

Enquire Now

    Garbage Disposal Replacement

    June 5, 2025

    The kitchen in a home is its heart, and a fully functioning garbage disposal makes a significant contribution to the kitchen’s cleanliness. But what do you do when your garbage disposal starts leaking? Suddenly, you find yourself in a situation where you have to deal with a dirty, smelly, and potentially clogged sink.

    The leaks from your disposal unit can be small or an indicator of more significant problems. Understanding the causes of a leaking garbage disposal, how to identify the source, and when to repair or replace it can save you time, money, and stress.

    Magnificent Plumbing wants to provide you with the best information you can utilize to make the best decision. Below is a complete guide to help you handle a garbage disposal leaking problem and find out when it is the right time to repair or replace it.

    Signs Garbage Disposal Leaking

    Common Signs Your Garbage Disposal is Leaking

    Before repairing or replacing, let’s first look at the signs that indicate problems with the garbage disposal in your kitchen:

    1. Water Under the Sink

    One of the most common indicators is the accumulation of water under the sink. Puddles, dampness, and even warped cabinet panels are strong indicators that water is leaking from the unit.

    2. Bad Smells

    Odors emanating from the sink might indicate food particles rotting within the system. Dirty organic materials can become a breeding ground for bacteria, which in turn produce nasty smells.

    3. Unusual Noises or Vibrations

    Increased rattling or vibrating sounds coming from the garbage disposal suggest damage to internal components, which could create additional problems in the form of leaking. The unit requires further inspections to determine the extent of the repair work necessary.

    4. Rust or Corrosion

    Over time, the metal body of your garbage disposal can corrode because of moisture. If its outer shell has rust spots or bubbles, this may indicate the entire unit’s deterioration and potential leaks.

    Garbage Disposal Leak Source

    Identifying the Source of the Leak

    To determine whether your garbage disposal requires repair or complete replacement, you should first find out the leak’s source. Each leak location can have different causes and solutions.

    1. Top Leak (Where the Sink Flange Connects to the Disposal)

    If the leak is found just below the sink, then it could be caused because of a loose sink flange that has deteriorated over time. The sink flange is a metal ring that mounts the garbage disposal to the sink and is designed to hold the disposal in a secure position. Additionally, loose mounting bolts or old plumber’s putty can lead to this problem.

    2. Side Leak (Where the Dishwasher Hose or Drain Pipe Connects to the Disposal)

    A kitchen waste disposal unit (garbage disposal) may also develop side leaks where the hose or drainpipe connects to the disposal. Over time, these parts loosen or become cracked and cause water to leak, especially when the disposal is in use.

    3. Bottom Leak (Unit Leaks from the Bottom)

    When a kitchen waste disposal unit begins leaking from the bottom, it could indicate that the motor casing or the unit’s internal seals have failed. Usually, such leaks are irreparable and need a replacement.

    When to Repair Your Garbage Disposal

    Certain issues in a garbage disposal can be resolved without requiring the entire unit replacement. If you face any of the below instances, your garbage disposal needs a repair:

    1. Loose Connections

    Leaks from hose fittings or mounting assemblies are common issues that can be resolved by tightening certain components. Such quick fixes are low-cost and do not require unit removal.

    2. Worn Gasket or Seal

    With time, gaskets located between disposals and sinks are susceptible to cracking or compressing. This gasket can be replaced, and doing so will stop leaks at the top of the unit.

    3. Clogged Drain Causing Backflow

    In some cases, unit problems are not centered around the device but rather a clogged drainpipe. Clogs have the capability of forcing water, which can leak from joints or seams. Fixing the drainage can resolve the matter completely.

    4. Tripped Reset Button

    For units that appear unresponsive or are not grinding properly, the reset button located underneath the disposal should be checked. Pressing this button can usually restore the motor and prevent additional issues that might cause leaks.

    Pro Tip: For safe inspection and repair of the garbage disposal, it is best to switch off the circuit breaker and disconnect the unit.

    Garbage Disposal replacement

    When to Replace Your Garbage Disposal

    Repairing the leak on your garbage disposal could only be a temporary measure of an unavoidable issue. These are the scenarios where it would be a lot easier and safer to just replace the unit.

    1. Leak Coming from the Bottom

    If the garbage disposal is leaking from the bottom, the most likely explanation is that the internal seals have failed. These are not serviceable parts, and in this case, the only feasible solution is a replacement.

    2. Rust and Corrosion

    If there is visible rust on the exterior of your garbage disposal, it is likely that the insides are also corroding. Once rust starts damaging the casing, the stray water it contains will compromise the watertight seal. And continued use can lead to bigger plumbing issues.

    3. Frequent Repairs

    If you have already spent money multiple times repairing the garbage disposal, then you understand that the cost of frequent service calls can become quite steep. Quite often, it is just more economical to replace the unit than to continually call for repairs.

    4. The Unit is Over 8 Years Old

    A good rule of thumb is that disposals last between 8 to 12 years. If it is older than that and starts working erratically or leaking from the bottom, chances are that it is reaching the end of its lifespan. It is often more economical to upgrade to a newer model than to continually repair a malfunctioning unit.

    5. Loud, Unusual Noises Even After Reset

    Strange sounds, such as grinding or struggling even after pressing the reset button, indicate possible internal damage to the garbage disposal. At this stage, repairing may not be the right option.

    Preventing Future Leaks

    When solving the current leaking issue with your garbage disposal, it is critical to apply measures to prevent future problems.

    • Always run cold water while using the garbage disposal. It will be harder for fats and oils to stick to the pipes.
    • Do not put stringy or fibrous foods such as celery, banana peels, or onion skins. They usually tangle with blades and stop proper functionality.
    • Avoid pouring grease and cooking oil into the garbage disposal. They form hardened clogs and increase pressure, causing potential leaks.
    • Use your disposal regularly to keep it working well and to stop the buildup of rust or corrosion from not using it.
    • To neutralize odor and remove buildup, clean the unit once a month with a mix of baking soda and vinegar.

    Hire Professional Plumber

    DIY vs. Professional Help

    Some leaks in garbage disposals can be fixed with a wrench and a YouTube tutorial. Most, however, need a professional touch. A DIY fix without proper tools or knowledge often leads to severe plumbing damage.

    Call a Professional If:

    • Disposal leakage occurs, particularly beneath the unit or at the bottom.
    • You do not have any useful knowledge of the leak’s origin.
    • No performance issues are resolved after pressing the reset button.
    • Older units, noisy during operation, or showing multiple signs of failure.

    From loose clamps to complete system overhauls, at Magnificent Plumbing, we’ve seen it all. Repair or replace? We will guide you through an honest evaluation of your situation.

    Call Plumber Now

    Call Plumber Now